I’m only weighing in to say that RPA nailed your answer. He is exactly right. In addition, any carpenter who would suggest red oak to replace QSWO is a bit suspect. Keep in mind the ‘quarter sawn’ description. It is that specifically that makes the appearance so unique (and pricey)

RPA is right, you will not get the same results from red oak. The 1/4 sawn white oak is definately the way to go. I have built lots of furniture out of both and both work fine. However, the look of the 1/4 sawn white oak way surpasses the red oak. Stay true to what you originally asked for and if the carpenter can’t do it…Find a different carpenter. Good luck.

Quarter sawn white oak will have medullary ray fleck that will not be apparent in red oak. Red oak is not a bad wood but don’t expect it to look the same. Quarter sawn white oak was a favorite of the arts and craft movement. Take a look at the mission style furniture from Stickley to get an idea why it was and is so popular.

You will pay significantly more for quarter sawn white oak. Here in New England it’s about twice as expensive as flat sawn red oak and sometimes hard to find.

Wait for the sample!